I doubt Carrie will be in the bottom three - she should win this competition. If she doesn't win then they should leave the voting up to Randy, Paula and Simon, ones who are already (or were) in the business - quit letting America vote because she is a natural at singing, she deserves to win.

Posted by: Lisa at April 10, 2005 08:43 PM

I didn't say she deserved to be in the bottom three, genius.

Deserving rarely has anything to do with the outcome on this show. The fact that Scott's still around proves that.

Posted by: Tanya at April 10, 2005 08:49 PM

Lisa is *yawn* fun, isn't she.

Posted by: Sekimori at April 10, 2005 10:33 PM

I wasn't indicating you said she "deserved" to be in the bottom three, genius.. was just putting my opinion out there that she probably wouldn't be in the bottom three if the voters were voting on real talent. She's a good singer, that's all.
*Yawn* .... yeah, as fun as everyone else posting to this site. Give me a break.

Posted by: Lisa at April 11, 2005 12:51 AM

And yet you keeeeeeep coming back. No one else will listen to your patronizing monologues? How odd.

Posted by: Tanya at April 11, 2005 07:31 AM

Carrie was god awful the other night, she totally butchered that Pat Benetar song and wtf was with her makeup? They made her look like a trailer park HO. Seriously, Constantine just blew the doors off everyone including Simon's little fave Carrie. Constantine is so obviously the one who should win I am astounded that he isnt getting 100% of the vote. That man is just so exciting to watch and after he performs I am so blown away I cant even remember what anyone before him sang.

Posted by: sandy at April 15, 2005 04:26 AM

My opinion thus far:

Carrie: sounds nice when she sings country but her voice doesnt fare well on other material. Her attempt at "rock" fell flat, sounded forced and she looked uncomfortable singing it. She should be on Nashville star NOT american idol

Anwar: He bores me to death. About as interesting as watching a hamster on his treadmill.

Scott: He looks like BTK with 50 lbs packed on, has a crappy attitude and cant sing to save his life. He should stick to singing in showers.

Federov: Very handsome, nice personality, decent voice but looks like a deer in headlights on stage and his voice is very uneven. I am amazed he is still there.

Bo: I originally like him but he is starting to bore me big time. He sounds the same all the time no matter what he is singing and he doesnt seem to be able to do anything but southern rock. He made no attempt at all to give the showtunes theme a chance, he just gave up. That annoyed me, its unprofessional not to give every performance your best.

Constantine: WOW....this man amazes me. He doesnt have the best voice in the competition but it is quite good and he knows how to use it to his advantage. He also has the most amazing charisma and stage presence I have ever seen. His performances make everyone else on the stage look like an amateur. He will win. I would stand in line for 3 days to buy a ticket to one of his concerts.

Vonzell: Nice voice but really boring performer. Nothing I havent seen before. As soon as she is done singing I totally forget what she sang. vonzell might have a future in music on some level but she has no chance of winning, she just doesnt stand out.

Posted by: sandy at April 15, 2005 04:38 AM